9am – 5pm Eastern, Monday – Friday
133 N Dupont Blvd Ste 103, Smyrna, DE 19977
Sale Tax Free Shopping!Can an iPad or Samsung tablet replace a fully rugged tablet in the field? In this edition of the Rugged Rundown, Bob discusses why he prefers purpose-built rugged equipment for demanding work, particularly in police and fire department applications.
His comparison centers on the Panasonic Toughbook FZ-G2 and the differences between a fully rugged Windows device and a consumer tablet fitted with a protective case. While lighter weight makes consumer tablets appealing, Bob argues that environmental protection, connectivity, and expansion options deserve just as much attention as the initial purchase price.
Budget Pressure and the Move to Consumer Tablets
Bob says he has noticed some police and fire departments moving away from fully rugged equipment in favor of devices such as iPads because of budget constraints.
The appeal is understandable: a consumer tablet may appear to offer the functions a department needs in a lighter package. However, Bob cautions against treating a tablet in a protective case as a direct replacement for equipment designed specifically for demanding environments.
For him, the decision comes down to suitability—whether the complete setup can handle the conditions and tasks it will encounter.
A Protective Case Is Only Part of the Equation
A rugged case can protect a consumer tablet, but Bob emphasizes that the device inside still matters. His concerns include moisture exposure and the temperature extremes a tablet might face when left in a vehicle in summer or winter.
The distinction he draws is between adding protection to a consumer device and choosing a purpose-built rugged system. A case alone should not be treated as evidence that the complete setup can withstand every condition associated with fieldwork.
The episode does not identify a specific iPad or Samsung model or compare published environmental ratings. Bob’s comments are therefore best understood as a warning to evaluate the exact device and enclosure—not as a specification-level assessment of every Apple or Samsung tablet.
Connectivity for Field Equipment
Another reason Bob favors fully rugged Windows tablets is their physical connectivity. He highlights USB and external display connections as examples of the ports that can matter when a tablet needs to work with other equipment.
The Panasonic FZ-G2 serves as his main example. He also mentions the Dell Latitude 7220 and Getac F110 as alternatives in the rugged-tablet category.
The episode does not provide a port-by-port comparison of those devices. Instead, Bob’s broader point is that buyers should consider how a tablet will connect to their existing equipment, rather than focusing only on its screen, camera, or portability.
Expansion Options on the Panasonic FZ-G2
Bob demonstrates an expansion option on the FZ-G2: a barcode scanner installed in what he refers to as the unit’s “xPAK.”
This illustrates one of the features he values in a rugged work device—the ability to configure the hardware for a particular task. In the example shown, barcode scanning is incorporated into the tablet rather than presented as a separate handheld accessory.
This is a brief look at the installed module, not a complete overview of the FZ-G2’s expansion choices or a demonstration of scanning performance.
Keyboard Options and Laptop-Style Use
Bob also points out that the FZ-G2 can connect to a keyboard when the job calls for more typing.
He acknowledges that keyboards are available for iPads, including Bluetooth options. His concern is not simply whether a keyboard can connect, but whether the complete tablet-and-keyboard combination offers the ruggedness needed for the intended work.
The video does not compare specific consumer-tablet keyboards or their protection ratings. The practical question it raises is whether every part of the setup—not just the tablet—fits the working environment.
The Tradeoff: Weight
Bob readily acknowledges a disadvantage of fully rugged tablets: weight. In his comparison, the iPad is the lighter option, while the FZ-G2 and the other rugged tablets he discusses involve a heavier device.
That tradeoff matters when equipment must be carried throughout a shift. Bob nevertheless prefers the rugged option for the demanding applications discussed, placing greater value on its protection, connections, and hardware flexibility.
No weights are measured in the episode, so this remains a qualitative comparison rather than a model-by-model portability test.
Bob’s Take: Choose for the Working Environment
For the police, fire, and field-service scenarios discussed, Bob favors a fully rugged tablet over a consumer tablet with an added case. His reasoning centers on environmental demands, physical connectivity, expansion options, and the ability to use a keyboard as part of a work-focused setup.
The lighter consumer device still has an advantage in portability. Bob’s message is to weigh that benefit against the requirements of the job—and to evaluate the complete configuration before replacing purpose-built rugged equipment.